Patricia Wrede recently wrote a book called "The Thirteenth Child," which is coming out soon from Tor, featuring an America that was never inhabited by American Indians. People are angry. I'm not going to touch on the many, many reasons that it's not a healthy premise for a book, because I can
link you to many other versions of that.I
am going to say that Lois McMaster Bujold has been commenting on the issue, and her latest has been an assertion that talking on the internet is
slanderous and silly (we have no
evidence that the book treats things carelessly --
you know, except for the many reports from people with ARCs that yes, it is a book that has a hole at its heart. Why don't we donate to American Indian tribal charities instead?)
It is a hilarious complaint. Her targets are some of the most active, involved members of anti-racist activities around.
karnythia founded Verb Noire and is working at Operation PUSH.
kate_nepveu and
popelizbet sent fans of color to WisCon with a fundraiser whose runoff went to the Carl Brandon Society. In fact,
this entire post contains only constructive responses to RaceFail. Furthermore, a number of the fans she's castigating for not doing Real Work for the American Indian/First Nations Communities
are tribally enrolled. They are doing Real Work for the American Indian/First Nations Communities every day with their friends and families. And not to bring the haunted specter of class into this, but of the people she addresses who
do not donate, some of them are not able to spend a dollar more than they need to.
But besides the many, many reasons that it is unwise to castigate an active community of radical people of color (to borrow
delux_vivens's phrase) and anti-racists for "not doing enough," why do so many fiction writers complain that we're paying too much attention to fiction? How many of them have, in other contexts, assured us that stories are what make us human? How many of them have, in other contexts, talked about the power of words? Do words only have power when they want them to? Do they honestly think that words and that fiction only serve the purpose they were initially intended to serve, and do they think that such purposes are
unimportant?